Source-verified state registry

New Jersey animal-cruelty convictions

PawWatch Registry publishes final convictions supported by an official court, prosecutor, law-enforcement, or government registry source. Records are rechecked for corrections and removals.

32 verified recordsReview in progressLast reviewed 2026-09-01

Coverage transparency

What PawWatch Registry has reviewed

Date range reviewed
Record-level official sources reviewed; statewide 2015-present backfill incomplete
Official sources checked
1

Official sources

Known gaps

  • Statewide and major local official sources have not been reviewed for the complete 2015-present period.
Source verified

Jeffrey Finlay

Brick Township, NJ

Conviction
Two final animal-cruelty counts involving severe neglect of cats and dogs.
Date
Sentenced 2025-04-25; exact plea date not stated
View verified record
Source verified

Johnnie Lee Nelson

Bridgeton, NJ

Conviction
Conspiracy to possess, train, transport, sponsor and exhibit dogs for an animal-fighting venture.
Date
Sentenced 2025-04-16; exact plea date not stated
View verified record
Source verified

Robert J. Hartobey

Not stated, NJ

Conviction
One count fourth-degree animal cruelty for kicking and punching his dog.
Date
Sentenced 2023-06-23; appellate affirmance 2024-10-25
View verified record
Source verified

David J. Silcott

Not stated, NJ

Conviction
Owning, possessing, or keeping animals for the purpose of fighting or baiting them.
Date
Sentenced 2017-05-08
View verified record
Source verified

Clifford Robbins

Toms River, NJ

Conviction
Third-degree animal cruelty for killing his dog by carbon-monoxide exposure from vehicle exhaust.
Date
Sentenced 2015-03-06; plea entered earlier
View verified record
Source verified

Hunter Roy

Maple Shade, NJ

Conviction
Fourth-degree cruelty to animals for engaging in sexual acts with dogs; separate CSAM offense also adjudicated.
Date
Pleaded guilty September 2025; sentenced January 2026
View verified record
Source verified

Bani J. Mezquititla

Asbury Park, NJ

Conviction
Two third-degree animal-cruelty convictions: torture/abuse resulting in a cat's death and sexual use of an animal.
Date
Pleaded guilty April 2024; sentenced 2024-06-13
View verified record
Source verified

Andrew Mayer

Toms River, NJ

Conviction
One count animal cruelty after driving onto river ice and leaving his dog in a sinking vehicle, resulting in the dog's death.
Date
Plea September 2016; sentenced 2017-02-17
View verified record
Source verified

Michael Ciarla

Pleasantville, NJ

Conviction
Third-degree cruelty to animals via torture after repeatedly slamming a door on a cat, breaking all limbs beyond repair.
Date
Plea August 2023; sentenced 2023-10-19
View verified record
Source verified

Edwin Sanabia

Atlantic City, NJ

Conviction
Two final animal-cruelty convictions in a case involving torture and killing of cats.
Date
Plea 2025-12-02; sentenced 2026-02-09
View verified record
Source verified

Tommy J. Watson

Clayton, NJ

Conviction
Conspiracy to possess, train and transport dogs for animal fighting; sponsoring/exhibiting dogs in an animal-fighting venture; separate ammunition offense.
Date
Plea 2025-05-16; sentenced 2026-05-22
View verified record
Source verified

Aimee Lonczak

Brick Township, NJ

Conviction
Two counts of animal cruelty arising from severe unsanitary conditions involving approximately 129 dogs, 43 cats, and two deceased dogs.
Date
Plea 2024-06-25; sentenced 2024-08-16
View verified record
Source verified

Donna Roberts

Shamong Township, NJ

Conviction
One count third-degree cruelty to animals for causing the deaths of six dogs by failing to provide proper care.
Date
Plea 2022-02-16; sentenced 2022-05-13
View verified record
Source verified

Allissa DeStefano

Toms River, NJ

Conviction
Animal cruelty for abandoning three dogs in a residence, resulting in their deaths.
Date
Plea 2021-07-23; sentenced 2021-10-15
View verified record
Source verified

Quintin Alec-Manning

Brick Township, NJ

Conviction
Animal cruelty for purposely striking and killing five geese with a motor vehicle.
Date
Plea 2021-03-15; sentenced 2021-05-05
View verified record
Source verified

William D. Stroemel

Maple Shade, NJ

Conviction
Third-degree animal cruelty for fatally shooting a neighbor's therapy dog with an air rifle.
Date
Plea 2020-04-29; sentenced 2021-01-06
View verified record
Source verified

Jonathon Correa

Brick Township, NJ

Conviction
Animal cruelty for leaving a dog caged outside in extreme heat, resulting in death.
Date
Plea 2019-09-30; sentenced 2020-01-10
View verified record
Source verified

Franklin Ziegler

Cape May, NJ

Conviction
Third-degree animal cruelty for killing and decapitating a seagull.
Date
Guilty plea before 2026-02-12; sentenced 2026-03-12
View verified record
Source verified

Tonya Fea

Boonton, NJ

Conviction
One third-degree animal-cruelty conviction for submerging a golden retriever puppy in a pond, causing death.
Date
Guilty plea 2021-08-12; sentenced 2021-10-05
View verified record
Source verified

Lamont Stephenson

Newark, NJ

Conviction
One animal-cruelty conviction for strangling the family dog; separate murder conviction.
Date
Guilty plea 2021-06-17; sentenced 2021-07-29
View verified record
Source verified

Haniyyah Barnes

Newark, NJ

Conviction
Animal cruelty for fatally throwing a neighbor's dog into traffic.
Date
Convicted October 2015; sentenced 2016-02-24
View verified record
Source verified

Donovan G. Hollingsworth

Evesham, NJ

Conviction
Third-degree cruelty to animals for fatally stabbing a Cane Corso during a robbery/homicide episode.
Date
Convicted 2023-08-31; sentenced 2024-02-09
View verified record
Source verified

Marlene Sandford

Middletown, NJ

Conviction
61 counts of animal cruelty involving more than 60 dogs and puppies kept in deplorable conditions.
Date
2023-10-19
View verified record
Source verified

Frank Nichols

Millville, NJ

Conviction
Felony conspiracy to transport, deliver and receive dogs intended for animal fighting
Date
2017-08-11
View verified record
Source verified

Lydell Harris

Vineland, NJ

Conviction
Felony conspiracy to sponsor/exhibit a dog in an animal-fighting venture; felony possession of a dog intended for fighting
Date
2017-08-10
View verified record
Source verified

Mario Atkinson

Asbury Park, NJ

Conviction
Sponsoring/exhibiting a dog in a dog fight; unlawful possession of a dog intended for fighting
Date
2017-06-15
View verified record