Source-verified state registry

Utah animal-cruelty convictions

PawWatch Registry publishes final convictions supported by an official court, prosecutor, law-enforcement, or government registry source. Records are rechecked for corrections and removals.

15 verified recordsReview in progressLast reviewed 2026-09-01

Coverage transparency

What PawWatch Registry has reviewed

Date range reviewed
Record-level official sources reviewed; statewide 2015-present backfill incomplete
Official sources checked
1

Official sources

Known gaps

  • Statewide and major local official sources have not been reviewed for the complete 2015-present period.
Source verified

Joshua Carroll

Ogden, UT

Conviction
One reduced count of torture of a companion animal, a class A misdemeanor, involving mistreatment of puppies.
Date
Sentenced September 2025
View verified record
Source verified

Kim Tibbets

Ogden, UT

Conviction
Aggravated cruelty to an animal arising from repeatedly shooting a dog with a BB gun.
Date
Sentenced 2018-06-12
View verified record
Source verified

Teresa Renae Clark

Salt Lake City, UT

Conviction
Two misdemeanor counts of animal cruelty involving the killing of two dogs.
Date
Pleaded guilty February 2020; sentenced March 2020
View verified record
Source verified

Monte Cuch

Vernal, UT

Conviction
Aggravated cruelty to an animal, reduced to a class A misdemeanor, for beating a puppy with a baseball bat.
Date
Plea September 2015; sentenced December 2015
View verified record
Source verified

Michael Paul Busico

Tooele, UT

Conviction
One count of torture of a companion animal, a third-degree felony, for setting a dog on fire; also pleaded guilty to a separate arson offense.
Date
Plea May 2022; sentenced 2022-07-13
View verified record
Source verified

Spencer Jens Pedersen

Provo, UT

Conviction
One count of torture of a companion animal, a third-degree felony, involving burning and torturing kittens.
Date
Plea December 2016; sentenced 2017-01-23
View verified record
Source verified

Memphis Shuihan Lor

Ogden, UT

Conviction
Four counts of torture of a companion animal, third-degree felonies, for throwing six puppies from a moving vehicle at highway speeds.
Date
Plea 2026-03-23; sentenced 2026-05-18
View verified record
Source verified

Jason Whittier

Not stated, UT

Conviction
One class B misdemeanor count of aggravated cruelty to an animal after police K-9 Endy died in a hot patrol vehicle.
Date
Plea 2017-10-02; sentenced 2017-11-13
View verified record
Source verified

Mikah M. Johnson

Salt Lake City, UT

Conviction
2 third-degree felony counts of torture of a companion animal; separate assault conviction.
Date
Guilty plea August 2016; sentenced 2016-11-04
View verified record
Source verified

Alvie Jared Grover

Not stated, UT

Conviction
One count of injuring or interfering with a police service animal, a third-degree felony, for shooting K-9 Tess.
Date
District plea/sentencing date not stated in retained appellate opinion; affirmed 2022-04-07
View verified record
Source verified

Torey Chase Massey

West Jordan, UT

Conviction
Cause Injury/Death to Police Service Animal (Dangerous Weapon), a third-degree felony, for fatally shooting Unified Police K-9 Dingo.
Date
Convicted 2019-04-19; sentenced 2019-08-26
View verified record